I love the timeless beauty of the Hudson Valley, where I live. Here, looking south.
By Caitlin Kelly
I won’t post the image here, obviously.
But it is green-ish — a pale image of the Statue of Liberty, a copy of my fingerprint (they take your biometrics), my photo (in black and white), my signature, gender and other details.
It also has a code that tells officials how I won this legal status — the drop-down menu of options as you go to renew it is very long. Last time I came back from Canada, the officer commented he rarely sees my category.
It’s a truly precious document.
I was born in Vancouver, Canada, lived in London, England ages two to five, then Toronto ages five to 30, with residence in Mexico, Paris and Montreal along the way.
But I was forever being mistaken for American — which every Canadian knows is not a compliment: too loud, too bossy, too driven, too direct. Walks too fast. Talks too fast. Wants too much.
Canadians prize quiet modesty and indirectness. They loathe conflict and are ambivalent or reluctant about celebrating heroes, money or celebrity — which is why Harry and Meghan chose wisely to move to Victoria, British Columbia. Most Canadians just don’t care.
My mother was born in New York and lived in a few places in the U.S., but she never liked it much and was glad to flee permanently to Canada. The irony is that I now live near her birthplace and she, in Victoria, near mine.
I love this elegant NYC restaurant, Via Carota
Why did I want to move to the U.S., and to New York?
My one word answer remains unchanged after all these years — ambition.
Canada is small, and offers limited opportunities for a big career in journalism and publishing, Even in a recession, and I’ve weathered three of them in New York since arriving in 1989, there are a lot of decent opportunities here and, key, people willing to hire me, staff or freelance.
There are many things about the U.S. — as you know if you read this blog regularly — that deeply trouble me: racism, violence, guns, sexism, income inequality. Not to mention current electoral politics.
But I’ve always been surprised by — and much appreciated — the willingness here to give me chances to prove myself. I am privileged, for sure: well-educated, white, able-bodied. And this is a country where money talks, so when people choose me, I know they do so with the confidence I’ll help them make more and not let them down.
Downtown Montreal has re-purposed some gorgeous bank buildings into cafes and co0-working spaces
I get it. I almost welcome the nakedness of this transaction.
Canadians are a different breed. Much more averse to risk. Slower to commit and quick to scuttle away from conflict.
In a smaller country, failure sticks and is more difficult to erase, deny or flee. I get it.
So I feel more at ease, in some ways, and certainly in New York, than I ever did in Toronto or Montreal.
I miss elements of my life in Canada and I really miss the deeper quality of those friendships.
And boy I do miss its cooler emotional temperature and impulse to discretion — sometimes I want to holler, here: “Enough! I don’t want to hear all your damn feelings!”
I find it exhausting and unwelcome.
I’ve also been fortunate here: owning an apartment, finding a loving, hard-working and accomplished husband and a few friends.
I’ve luckily ticked many of my life boxes, and have — still — some serious professional ambitions yet to satisfy, like hoping to write and sell two more non-fiction books.
I also came here because I had some cool American relatives and ancestors, like a Chicago developer, or the bullfighter, or the archeologist or the diplomat or the small aircraft pilot with the almond farm.
I found them all so intriguing.
So, for $540, my new green card will buy me another American decade.
I pray to be alive and healthy when it expires.
Have you left your native country to settle permanently abroad?
Are you happy with how it turned out?